Mario`s Pizza in Niagara Falls

Mario`s Pizza in Niagara Falls
4.5 / 5
50 reviews

307 Prospect St, Niagara Falls, NY 14303-1105, Niagara Falls

Overview

Cuisine
  • Italian
  • Pizza
  • Fast Food

Restaurant Hours

Monday

08:00 - 17:00

Tuesday

08:00 - 17:00

Wednesday

08:00 - 17:00

Thursday

00:00 - 17:00

Friday

00:00 - 17:00

There is gluten free menu ?

There is gluten free pizza on their menu.

Review

Add rating restaurant:
Mario`s Pizza
JM
John Miles
google
11.21.2024
5/5

Best New York style pizza I have had in a long time

Mario`s Pizza
MB
Mayank Bhargava
google
11.13.2018
4/5

Nice to find delicious pizza after the long hot queue for Maid of the Mist. Very helpful staff, small place so be prepared for 30 min wait. Pizza is worth the wait. Do try their "desi" pizza catering to the Indian tourists - garlic, ginger, coriander, onions and peppers.

Mario`s Pizza
JC
J C
google
10.21.2018
5/5

I usually avoid pizza in tourist areas but I just wanted a quick bite and saw “pizza by the slice”. Wow! This pizza was excellent and the service was fantastic!

Mario`s Pizza
JT
Janis Timlick
google
09.20.2018
5/5

Best pizza ever! I had a slice of the vegi pizza. I especially loved the crisp crust. The sauce, cheese, the vegis all superb. Service great. Even had water for my dog!

Mario`s Pizza
ks
klea smile
google
09.18.2018
5/5

Friendly staff and good pizza

Mario`s Pizza
sf
suhair fadhil
google
08.15.2018
5/5

Quick service and friendly staff.pizza was delicious

Mario`s Pizza
CJ
Chalee Jozwiak
google
08.09.2018
4/5

Pizza and salad for dinner. Pepperoni was small and crispy, loaded with cheese.

Mario`s Pizza
BB
Bryan Belnap
google
08.04.2018
5/5

Amazing! Just want I expected from a pizza place called Mario's. Good outdoor seating, close to parking. Most importantly, great food.

Mario`s Pizza
SK
Shawn King
google
06.13.2018
5/5

Great pizza, great service. Kids loved it.

Mario`s Pizza
MR
Michele Rossi
google
06.01.2018
5/5

Great pizza close to Italian style. We are from Italy and we got it with no expectations. I have to admit that we were impressed by the taste of this pizza, close to what we have at home. And it was inexpensively be too. Good job!!!

Mario`s Pizza
PR
Pedro Rodriguez
google
05.07.2018
5/5

The best pizza in Niagara Falls.

Mario`s Pizza
Thiccum
google
04.22.2018
5/5

Really amazing pizza and nice staff. Also has vegan cheese which is excellent.

Mario`s Pizza
VS
Vladimir Simić
google
02.06.2018
4/5

Fast service and nice outdoor seating. We ordered pepperoni pizza. It was quite decent, but also unexpectedly salty.

Mario`s Pizza
QS
Quentin Sharp
google
01.22.2018
5/5

I love pizza and this was definitely a top 10 place. Try it you wont regret it

Mario`s Pizza
SI
Shiva Iyer
google
11.19.2017
5/5

Excellent New York pizza. We first chose another pizza place in the area over this one since their star rating was higher. Big mistake. We had Mario’s pizza another day afterwards and it was so much better. We ordered another pie after we tried out the Primavera pizza, just a cheese pie with jalapeño, which was amazing too. It was so good we went back the next day to order more to take back on our ride home! Highly recommend!

Mario`s Pizza
lh
lisamarie huckabay
google
11.18.2017
4/5

Just wanted a quick bite so a slice is what i was cravin. Went here and was not disappointed. Ingredients were fresh and flavorful. The slices were huge as I could barely finish mine and at the same time so good I wanted more. If I had more time in Niagara Falls I definitely would have had another meal there! This is a great little local joint to support if you're into supporting the locals.

Mario`s Pizza
YJ
Yugal Jindle
google
11.06.2017
5/5

Surprised by the quality and the juicy pizza.Not too heavy and delicious.Do try the Desi Pizza, will remind you of the Joe's pizza on time square

Mario`s Pizza
BL
Bonnie Lawrence
google
10.06.2017
2/5

Although I checked on line, the place was closed when I arrived. What a disappointment as it's the only place I've found in Niagara Falls that has GF pizza. I was told by a friend that they have closed for the season. It's difficult to get to during the summer as it's right in the center of the tourist district and parking can be a problem.

Mario`s Pizza
PL
Pavl Lee
google
10.04.2017
5/5

Great service and tasty pizza. Little pricy but worth it

Mario`s Pizza
DM
Denise Mollfulleda
google
09.14.2017
4/5

Did a takeout order while visiting Niagara Falls. Although when I got back to my hotelroom I realized they had forgotten to add chicken to my pizza, I went back and they did it right away. Flavor was fine, and staff were friendly. Will eat here again when in the area.

Mario`s Pizza
AO
Alex Obrusnik
google
09.08.2017
5/5

A bit pricey but worth it. Pizza is amazing. Even has vegan cheese for the odd vegans in the family...

Mario`s Pizza
KJ
Kristina Jones
google
08.22.2017
5/5

Pizza... very satisfying. This place will surprise you. Fast, efficient, and courteous service. The bill was fair I would say.

Mario`s Pizza
MS
Misti Sedam
google
08.01.2017
5/5

Hands down best pizza I've had! Of you go to Niagara falls, you have to try this!

Mario`s Pizza
NI
Nayceer IQ
google
07.18.2017
4/5

The pizza i had was delicious but it wasnt heated up. Even so, it was still really good so i think it deserves 4 stars from the potential of how good it would've been heated up

Mario`s Pizza
CP
Chris Perras
google
06.09.2017
1/5

Both their Facebook page and Google say they are open today, 29JUN2020... And that is absolutely false... Friday Saturday and Sunday only... epic fail

Mario`s Pizza
JB
Jeannine Balnis
google
06.02.2017
5/5

Ordered a plain cheese pizza and we really enjoyed it. Delicious! Pretty inside, love the dark maroon wall color and chalkboard menu.

Mario`s Pizza
dbaxxxxx
google
04.14.2017
5/5

It hit the spot after seeing the Maid of the Mist!

Mario`s Pizza
TC
Teeyada Cannon
google
04.13.2017
1/5

Went in order a pizza!! Pizza was cold so went back and they had on no gloves touching my pizza! Like it’s a virus going around right now and you have on no gloves touching my pizza! Very disappointed pizza was not that good. Kids was upset

Mario`s Pizza
PB
PinkVelvet Bird
google
02.05.2017
4/5

Vegan za! Wish they had vegan sausage.

Mario`s Pizza
DR
Diana Rodas
google
01.27.2017
4/5

Came here after our awesome visit to the falls. Pizza is thin crust and freshly made. Pretty good, we were all satisfied. Their 18" pizza fed 5 of us.

Mario`s Pizza
DP
Donna Pollow
google
01.24.2017
5/5

A nice and cozy pizza shop. Great for a quick bite to eat. If you like thin pizza like I do this is the place. It's a little pricey but I'm going back again. I crave this.

Mario`s Pizza
IM
Irsik Maria
google
10.16.2016
5/5

Very tasty pizza!

Mario`s Pizza
SB
S B
google
10.04.2016
5/5

We ordered a pizza to pick up and bring back to the hotel. Food was ready when they said it would be, the order was correct and the pizza delicious! Would definitely stop by again if we happened to be in the area.

Mario`s Pizza
TC
Tim Cichos
google
09.09.2016
4/5

Good pizza but I'm a deep dish guy!

Mario`s Pizza
TC
Tim Cichos
google
09.06.2016
4/5

Decent food but very limited seating.

Mario`s Pizza
KH
Kylie Harvey
google
08.20.2016
4/5

Great Food. Fast Service. Good price

Mario`s Pizza
JP
Jason Paul
google
07.26.2016
5/5

Awsome pizza we travel 2 1/2 hours just so we can get a pie

Mario`s Pizza
TN
Tina Nyongesa
google
07.19.2016
5/5

I have fond memories of this place. The pizza is great! I am looking forward to the next time we are in town.

Mario`s Pizza
JA
Jodi Asbury
google
06.19.2016
5/5

We visited Mario's on a Saturday night around 8 pm & it was very busy, I suggest the pizza by the slice if you are going to the falls afterwards to avoid the wait. Pizza was delicious! Worth the wait!

Mario`s Pizza
JR
Johnny Rush
google
06.10.2016
4/5

Chicken sausage + Peppers

Mario`s Pizza
NR
Nisha R
google
06.04.2016
1/5

My son is allergic to wheat and milk. So we ordered gluten free vegan pizza from here yesterday and he threw up after the very first bite. I mentioned about his allergy before order, but unfortunately it doesn’t matter to them..but a lot to us. He slept on empty stomach just because of their carelessness. Please don’t order here.

Mario`s Pizza
CS
Christina Shifton
google
05.17.2016
5/5

Great pizza and location can't be beat. Has both indoor and outdoor seating. We got slices, which were heated quickly. Whole pizzas are cooked to order and seem to come out quickly too. A great lunch option just a few steps from the Falls.

Mario`s Pizza
MS
Matt Snowdon
google
05.12.2016
5/5

Great gluten free pizza, which also came with its own sealed pizza cutter to prevent contamination. Highly recommended for not gluten free pizza too.

Mario`s Pizza
JM
Jeremy McQueary
google
05.07.2016
5/5

Amazing pizza! My wife is gluten free and she said it was the best GF pizza she has had. Well done!

Mario`s Pizza
SC
Shorya Consul
google
04.08.2016
5/5

Came here with a friend. As a place in the middle of a tourist attraction, it's a great value for money option. We got a pizza to split between us and it came piping hot. The best part was the crust (not the flimsy thin-crust you usually get).

Mario`s Pizza
KM
Kirk Metzger
google
03.25.2016
5/5

Amazing New York style Pizza! Staff was friendly and helpful. You won’t be disappointed!

Mario`s Pizza
JM
J Miles
google
03.24.2016
4/5

While the pizza was a bit pricey to what I'm used to pay, the pizza was great! We had the meat lover and the cheese. Back on the price, it had most to do with the drinks, because the pizzas had huge pieces, while the drinks were all single bottle servings. That said, if you are looking to eat at Niagara, this is a great stop. I should mention it has limited seating for about 20 people inside, but there is lot of outside seating and nearby shade trees at the park. We just took ours back to the hotel.

Mario`s Pizza
RS
Ray Salmeron
google
03.22.2016
5/5

Awesome pizza! Cheesy with delicious pepperoni, amazing flavor and the crust is crispy! Restaurant was clean and served us fast even on a busy day! Just as a small experience, I was already out of the restaurant when my coke fell and busted open. When I walked in and explained what happened they gave me a free coke! I thought it was very nice of them to treat customers this way!

Mario`s Pizza
BM
Buffie Mead
google
03.15.2016
5/5

Love the crust crisp, and chewy. I really like the 5 cheese pizza.

Mario`s Pizza
ET
Eric T. Huffman
google
02.13.2016
5/5

Fast and filling NY style pizza that had great sidewalk seating to enjoy the weather and people watch.

Your question has been sent.

Expect an answer!

Thank!

Your review has been submitted.

Order food

Reservation

Want to order over the phone?

Call 17162822080

Thank you for being with us!

We will call you back!